Sarnia’s police chief on suspension is now under scrutiny in a criminal probe following a complaint from a local business owner and ex-city council member. The Ontario Inspectorate of Policing forwarded the complaint to York Regional Police due to suspicions of potential criminal activities. A representative from York Regional Police confirmed an active criminal investigation but refrained from disclosing further specifics.
The inquiry was initiated after Nathan Colquhoun lodged a complaint earlier this year, highlighting allegations concerning Chief Derek Davis’ recruitment practices and personal consulting engagements. Colquhoun expressed to CBC News via email that the complaint focused on Davis’ behavior. Additionally, Colquhoun, who owns and writes for The Sarnia Journal, alleged that Davis misused public resources by issuing libel notices to the publication.
Davis, who assumed the role of chief in 2022, has been on paid suspension since May amid an external investigation into allegations of workplace harassment. Earlier this year, Davis initiated and subsequently withdrew a $1.5 million defamation lawsuit against Colquhoun and his media company.
Kelly Ash, the chair of the Sarnia Police Services Board, acknowledged public frustration in a recent social media post but refrained from elaborating on the criminal investigation. Interim leadership for the Sarnia police service is being provided by Toronto’s former Deputy Police Chief Mike Federico in Davis’ absence.
Efforts to reach Davis for comment by CBC News have been unsuccessful. CBC News has also requested a copy of the complaint and supporting documents from Colquhoun.